A police investigation into a former Melbourne gynaecologist, Dr. Simon Gordon, concerning allegations of performing unnecessary surgeries has been concluded without charges. The inquiry was initiated in February following a referral from former Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan. Victoria Police announced on Tuesday that they would not be proceeding with the investigation, citing insufficient information to take the matter further at this time.
Investigation Details and Police Statement
The allegations against Dr. Gordon, who previously practiced at Epworth hospitals, surfaced in a report by ABC’s Four Corners. These claims suggested that some female patients may have undergone surgery for severe endometriosis, despite pathology results not supporting such a diagnosis. Dr. Gordon has consistently denied the accusations leveled against him.
A spokesperson for Victoria Police stated, “Victoria Police has completed the assessment of the referral. Based on the information provided, we are unable to take the matter further at this time.” The spokesperson also added that “Any new information provided to police will be thoroughly assessed,” leaving the door open for future action should further evidence emerge.
Referral and Patient Concerns
The referral to the police was made by then-Premier Jacinta Allan in February, who at the time emphasized that victims of unnecessary procedures deserved justice. Her office confirmed the referral, highlighting the seriousness with which the government viewed the allegations.
The case has drawn significant attention, with several law firms reporting that they have been contacted by hundreds of former patients of Dr. Gordon. Firms such as Arnold Thomas and Becker have been fielding complaints, indicating a widespread impact on individuals who sought treatment from the surgeon.
One former patient, Mary Spanos, shared her experience. Ms. Spanos, 30, underwent surgery in 2022. She stated that subsequent medical assessments indicated she suffered complications from the procedure, and her medical records reportedly showed no evidence of endometriosis being removed. Her account underscores the distress and potential harm experienced by some patients.
Hospital and Regulatory Actions
Epworth Healthcare, where Dr. Gordon practiced, has taken steps to address the concerns raised. In March, the hospital group announced the formation of an independent expert panel tasked with reviewing its clinical governance arrangements. This review was a direct response to the allegations and the volume of complaints from former patients.
Prior to the police referral, Epworth Healthcare had already referred concerns regarding Dr. Gordon to the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA) in October of the previous year. The hospital group stated its commitment to cooperating with all relevant authorities throughout these processes.
Dr. Gordon reportedly retired from Epworth in 2025 and has surrendered his medical registration. In August, it was confirmed that the medical regulator had referred Dr. Gordon to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) following its own investigation into the matter.
Broader Impact and Support for Endometriosis Patients
The allegations surrounding Dr. Gordon’s practice have contributed to a broader conversation about the diagnosis and treatment of endometriosis in Australia. In response to these and other concerns, both the Victorian and federal governments launched initiatives in April aimed at providing enhanced support for patients suffering from endometriosis.
These government measures include a range of support services designed to improve access to diagnosis, treatment, and ongoing care for individuals affected by the condition. The focus is on ensuring that patients receive appropriate and evidence-based care, addressing historical gaps in understanding and treatment pathways.
Conclusion
While the police investigation into Dr. Simon Gordon has been dropped due to insufficient evidence for further action at this time, the allegations have prompted significant reviews and actions. Epworth Healthcare is undertaking a review of its clinical governance, and regulatory bodies continue to assess the situation. The broader impact has also spurred government initiatives to bolster support for endometriosis patients, highlighting the ongoing efforts to improve care and accountability within the healthcare system.
